Showing posts with label robyn sisman. Show all posts
Showing posts with label robyn sisman. Show all posts

23 July 2010

Cover Win / Fail: THE PERFECT COUPLE?

So today I was pre-ordering some books that are coming out soon and one that I wanted to pre-order was also THE PERFECT COUPLE by Robyn Sisman. I've had an eye on it for months - the story sounded *fantastic* and the cover that was leaked looked really cute too. So I was all ready to pre-order my copy when, to my horror, I discovered that the cover has been changed - but sadly not upgraded ... So I figured we have a perfect pick for another installment of this feature!
As always, I mean no disrespect or offence, I'm just expressing my humble silly little opinion.



Cover WIN: The original cover that was posted on Chick Lit Reviews, but never confirmed
Cover FAIL: The official cover

I'll admit the original cover doesn't seem to be particulary true to the story as the couple hardly look like they're feuding all over the place, but but but it was so bright and cute and lovely - combined with the awesome plot it would totally make me pick the book up in a bookshop. I swear I would have bought it today if the cover hadn't been changed.

I'm sorry to say, but I strongly dislike the new cover. As you may know, I'm a huge fan of covers with drawings on them, but this drawing is just plain horrible to me - it's a nice concept that seems to fit the story, but terribly executed. As opposed to the previous draft (left), which screams Fun, the new cover tells me this is a story about Boring Old People and thus definitely not something I'd care to read. Which is strange, because I love the sound of the plot, but the cover just completely contrasts with it and thus puts me off too much.

Soooo I'm afraid it appears I'll have to wait for the paperback in this case and hope it gets a better cover before I spend my money on it.

Funnily enough, I've featured the covers of a Robyn Sisman book here before - remember my little rant about the paperback cover of A Hollywood Ending?

Seriously, why fix something that's not broken?

13 June 2010

Cover WIN / FAIL: A Hollywood Ending + Brontë video!

Firstly, sorry - there will be no IMM this week. I've only received one book and it feels sort of silly to feature one single book soooo I've decided I'll just post it along with the books I receive in the next week; trust me, I have some fantastic books on the way and I hope they show up in the next few days because I'm just sooo excited! :)

Secondly, instead of IMM, I've decided to do another Cover Win/Fail feature seeing how it's been a while since the last one. Today I'll be discussing the UK hardcover and paperback covers for A HOLLYWOOD ENDING by Robyn Sisman - have a look at them below ...



Cover WIN: the hardback cover
Personally, I think this cover is absolute PERFECTION and I adore pretty much everything about it - the illustration, the font, the colours etc. I haven't read the book yet, but it seems to fit the title well, don't you think? Beauuuutiful!

Cover FAIL: the paperback cover
As I said, I love the UK hardback cover so I struggle to understand why someone would want to change it at all, let alone to this pinkish mess. It's not terribly ugly, but for me it just doesn't work - the backgroud colour isn't too bad as it stands out nicely, but I really don't like neither the font nor the boring illustration. I wouldn't mind this cover too much if it was the original one, but having seen the hardback cover, the paperback one just fails (imho), end of.

So yes, that's why I bought the hardcover copy, even if it was nearly twice as expensive, but the fantastic cover is totally worth the money. I'm still confused about WHY they changed the original cover, hmmm. Oh and there's also the US cover, which you can see on the right (click to enlarge) and I have to say I like this one too, but not quite as much as the original UK one.

Lastly, I came across a fantastic video the other day and I wanted to share it with you all - it was posted on the Allison and Busby blog and it shows the awesomeness and kickassness of the Brontë sisters (in action figure form, heh). It's fantastic so check it out below. :)